sounds good to me

OK, I'm almost through with the first set of teams.
Looks like I will pick up all relevant teams which went bOT until season 9 ending.

This wil be 8 and I think max 3 should be selected.

To have compares for later selections, we will start with 20 points for 1st place, 18 points for 2nd place and so on, regardless of the "missing" 2 teams to have a set of 10.

I think I will be able to post all 8 teams at the weekend.

OK, here are the first 8 teams selected for the HOF voting.
Each manager can give a complete voting sheet, with granting each team voting points. The highest points (20) should be voted the team the manager thinks deservse the most to enter the MONARCHS REGION HALL OF FAME, the second deserving team should get 2 points less (18), the third one again 2 points less (16) and so on. The last team should get 6 points.
The Aces, Mayhem, trestleberg and Zingers had only 4 seasons in the 1.1 league, which means they would need a TOP 3 place to get into the HOF. For all other teams this normally would not be required. But since only 8 teams are on the list, only 3 teams will be granted a HOF spot anyway.
The voting is open until 01.03.2015
Then I will sum the votes up and will anounce the 3 winning teams.

The 5 teams which did not get enough voting points will not be eligible for 2 seasons, so earliest season 18.

Selected teams:
Jena Yellow Aces
Mayhem
AFC Luku Tábor
trestleberg
Casate New Canaries
Dutch Tigers
Rivne Monarchs
Zingers

In DETAILS

Jena Yellow Aces
JohnDorian
In with season 1
reached 1.1 in season 2
out with Season 5 (only 4 seasons in the 1.1)

Record

LEAGUE lower 1.1 (1 Season)
Wins Losses Points For Points Against Win Percentage
14 2 734 121 87,5%

Wins Postseason Losses Postseason Points For Points Against Win Percentage Postseason
1 1 27 26 50,00%

LEAGUE 1.1 or higher (4 seasons)
Wins Losses Points For Points Against Win Percentage
55 9 2663 791 85,94%

Wins Postseason Losses Postseason Points For Points Against Win Percentage Postseason
6 2 123 65 75,00%

SUPERCUP (5 seasons)
Wins Losses Points For Points Against Win Percentage
66 9 3737 554 88,00%

Wins Postseason Losses Postseason Points For Points Against Win Percentage Postseason
2 3 83 98 40,00%

CoC
Wins Losses Points For Points Against Win Percentage
3 2 113 92 60,00%

Won League Championship in league 1.1 in Season 2
Won NC Conference Championships in Season 2 and 3
Won Division Title AC East in league 2.1 in season 1
Won Division Title NC North in league 1.1 in Season 2, 3 and 4

Went to the post season in season 1 in league 2.1 (conference championship exit)
Went to the post season in season 2 in league 1.1 (league title)
Went to the post season in season 3 in league 1.1 (conference championship)
Went to the post season in season 4 in league 1.1 (conference championship exit)

Went to supercup playoffs in season 1 (2. round exit), 2 (1. round exit) and 4 (2. round exit)

Went to CoC in Season 3 (first round exit) and season 4 (4th round exit, last 8 teams)

The Aces were the best team in Season 2, won ALL games in a perfect season including the playoffs.
They then lost their first game in week 3 of season 3, the first since the Conference Championship game of the 2.1 in Season 1
Still they won the conference and lost in the Bowl against a strong Killer Bees team.
In season 4 they went perfect again in the regular season, but lost the Conference Championship against the Leopards. They also had a quite decent run in the Champs of Champs reaching the last 8 teams field.
After midseason of season 5 they went BOT and finished still with an 8-8 record.

Why in the HOF?
Early on team in league 2.1 (started basically on day 1 the game went live, 5th September 2011), which not only won the league in the early days, they also were for the first 3 seasons in the 1.1 one of the team you had to beat to win it all.
They were one of the first teams playing this game, when it went life and never looked back, until they fell BOT.

Why not in the HOF?
The amount of competitive teams in the early days were limited and they only stayed in the 1.1 for 4 seasons, so did not play really long.

Mayhem
almoraz
In with season 1
reached 1.1 in season 2
out with season 5 (only 4 seasons in the 1.1)

Record

LEAGUE lower 1.1 (1 Season)
Wins Losses Points For Points Against Win Percentage
10 6 269 281 62,5%

Wins Postseason Losses Postseason Points For Points Against Win Percentage Postseason
0 1 3 7 0,00%

LEAGUE 1.1 or higher (4 seasons)
Wins Losses Points For Points Against Win Percentage
22 42 1351 1774 34,38%

Wins Postseason Losses Postseason Points For Points Against Win Percentage Postseason
2 1 66 34 66,67%

SUPERCUP (5 seasons)
Wins Losses Points For Points Against Win Percentage
40 35 1805 1397 53,33%

Wins Postseason Losses Postseason Points For Points Against Win Percentage Postseason
0 0 0 0 0,00%

No participation in CoC

Won Division Title NC East in league 1.1 in Season 2

Went to the post season in season 1 in league 2.2 (wildcard exit)
Went to the post season in season 2 in league 1.1 (conference championship exit)

Mayhem was also one of the first teams to play the game, joined late in season 1 in the 2.2 (right before the playoffs) and they had basically one very good season in the 1.1 in season 2.
They went into the playoffs and went all the way to the conference championship game, where they lost to a strong Aces team.
After that season the team had only losing seasons and went BOT after gameday 6 in season 5.

Why in the HOF?
One of the early storming teams, they were for the very first 1.1 (Season 2) one of the best teams in the league.

Why not in the HOF?
Many of the great records and results in season 2 were based on BOT games and when the competition got stronger and the human teams got stronger and more teams went into 1.1, the mayhem did collapse and never got back on their feet.

AFC Luku Tábor
czluku
In with season 1
reached 1.1 in season 2
out with Season 6

Record

LEAGUE lower 1.1 (1 Season)
Wins Losses Points For Points Against Win Percentage
10 6 418 180 62,50%

Wins Postseason Losses Postseason Points For Points Against Win Percentage Postseason
1 1 55 17 50,00%

LEAGUE 1.1 or higher (5 seasons)
Wins Losses Points For Points Against Win Percentage
33 47 1572 2738 41,25%

Wins Postseason Losses Postseason Points For Points Against Win Percentage Postseason
0 1 7 14 0,00%

SUPERCUP (6 seasons)
Wins Losses Points For Points Against Win Percentage
60 30 2792 1321 66,67%

Wins Postseason Losses Postseason Points For Points Against Win Percentage Postseason
0 0 0 0 0,00%

No participation in CoC

Won Division Title AC East in league 1.1 in Season 2

Went to the post season in season 1 in league 2.2 (divisional playoffs exit)
Went to the post season in season 2 in league 1.1 (wildcard exit)

Dominant Force in Season 2 in the AC East, lost only to later playoff bound teams.
After that season was always in the shadow of the Dolni Chabry Patriots and even the Strike Team.
Left the game early in Season 6, so that the team went 0-16 in that season.

Why in the HOF?
Division winner in season 2 and basically one of the first teams of RZA at all (came in about 1 month after season 1 started).

Why not in the HOF?
Won the division in the early days with a lot of BOTs still in the game.
After a lot more human competition came in, the team went never back into the playoffs until the manager left.

trestleberg
greydog
In with season 2
reached 1.1 in season 3
out with season 6 (only 4 seasons in the 1.1)

Record

LEAGUE lower 1.1 (1 Season)
Wins Losses Points For Points Against Win Percentage
0 0 0 0 0,0%

Wins Postseason Losses Postseason Points For Points Against Win Percentage Postseason
0 0 0 0 0,00%

LEAGUE 1.1 or higher (4 seasons)
Wins Losses Points For Points Against Win Percentage
37 27 1452 1523 57,81%

Wins Postseason Losses Postseason Points For Points Against Win Percentage Postseason
2 3 32 99 40,00%

SUPERCUP (5 seasons)
Wins Losses Points For Points Against Win Percentage
47 13 2034 639 78,33%

Wins Postseason Losses Postseason Points For Points Against Win Percentage Postseason
0 0 0 0 0,00%

No participation in CoC

No titles won

trestleberg came in to the game in league 2.2 in season 2, after regular season and after supercup division games and did not play a single meaningful game in that season.
The team did flush right into the league 1.1 for season start of season 3 and was always one of the winning teams, but did never won any title.
After the 6th gameday in season 6 did the team went BOT.

Why in the HOF?
The team went straight into the 1.1 and were in the playoffs 3 times in a row.

Why not in the HOF?
trestleberg had basically never a signature win against any strong team in each season they were in the 1.1. They never won a title and they never went very far in the playoffs.


Casate New Canaries
Satanchia
In with season 1
reached 1.1 in season 2
out with Season 7

Record

LEAGUE lower 1.1 (1 Season)
Wins Losses Points For Points Against Win Percentage
7 9 215 312 43,75%

Wins Postseason Losses Postseason Points For Points Against Win Percentage Postseason
0 0 0 0 0,00%

LEAGUE 1.1 or higher (6 seasons)
Wins Losses Points For Points Against Win Percentage
57 39 2423 1816 59,38%

Wins Postseason Losses Postseason Points For Points Against Win Percentage Postseason
0 1 28 59 0,00%

SUPERCUP (7 seasons)
Wins Losses Points For Points Against Win Percentage
84 21 4917 770 80,00%

Wins Postseason Losses Postseason Points For Points Against Win Percentage Postseason
0 0 0 0 0,00%

No participation in CoC

No titles won

Went to the post season in season 6 in league 1.1 (wildcard exit)

The Canaries came into the game late in season 1 (league 2.1) and had the unfortunate draw to get into the most crowded division of the early 1.1.
Two league champions came from that league in later years and the Canaries were always 1 or 2 steps behind.
The finished never higher than 3rd in the division, and reached the playoffs only once.
Still they managed to get a winning record over their career and not many teams were happy to play them.
The left after another 3rd place finish in season 7 and went BOT before season rollover.

Why in the HOF?
One of the early tough teams in the AC, suffered mainly because of the inner division competition and the playoff rules.
Some early playoff participants were much stronger than this team left out of the playoffs over most of their career.

Why not in the HOF?
The Canaries never made it big. They went to the playoffs once in 6 season in the 1.1 and they went never to the playoffs in the supercup.

Dutch Tigers
Regulus
In with season 2
reached 1.1 in season 3
out with Season 8

Record

LEAGUE lower 1.1 (1 Season)
Wins Losses Points For Points Against Win Percentage
8 8 234 278 50,00%

Wins Postseason Losses Postseason Points For Points Against Win Percentage Postseason
0 0 0 0 0,00%

LEAGUE 1.1 or higher (6 seasons)
Wins Losses Points For Points Against Win Percentage
62 34 2948 1371 64,58%

Wins Postseason Losses Postseason Points For Points Against Win Percentage Postseason
3 5 157 207 37,50%

SUPERCUP (7 seasons)
Wins Losses Points For Points Against Win Percentage
83 22 5544 1042 79,05%

Wins Postseason Losses Postseason Points For Points Against Win Percentage Postseason
0 2 21 57 0,00%

No participation in CoC

Won Division Title AC South in league 1.1 in season 3,4,5,6 and 7

Went to the post season in season 3 in league 1.1 (wildcard exit)
Went to the post season in season 4 in league 1.1 (conference championship exit)
Went to the post season in season 5 in league 1.1 (conference championship exit)
Went to the post season in season 6 in league 1.1 (wildcard exit)
Went to the post season in season 7 in league 1.1 (wildcard exit)

Went to supercup playoffs in season 6 (1. round exit) and 7 (1. round exit)

The Dutch Tigers came in late of the second season (2.2) and flushed right into the 1.1 for season 3.
They won their division for the next 5 seasons and went BOT before last gameday in season 8.
They never made a big splash in the supercup but were always a team to play in the playoffs.
Often they were a bit unlucky to get one of the two power house teams from the AC North in that time in the first round, an early exit was more or less fact before the game.
When they were able to avoid those teams in the first rounds, they normally meet the last team of that division standing in the conference final to get the pink slip there.

Why in the HOF?
They had to build basically in the first weeks of season 3 and never looked back.
It was always clear they would have a hard time against the older teams, but they fought their way 5 seasons in the row into the playoffs.
Always in the shadow of the few bigger and older teams at that time.

Why not in the HOF?
Played in a quite easy division, at least at the beginning and were basically only playoff bound because of that division title.
Once they meet tougher teams they folded.

Rivne Monarchs
Ulmar
In with season 1
reached 1.1 in season 2
out with Season 9

Record

LEAGUE lower 1.1 (1 Season)
Wins Losses Points For Points Against Win Percentage
14 2 437 78 87,5%

Wins Postseason Losses Postseason Points For Points Against Win Percentage Postseason
2 1 91 27 66,67%

LEAGUE 1.1 or higher (4 seasons)
Wins Losses Points For Points Against Win Percentage
72 56 4025 2936 56,25%

Wins Postseason Losses Postseason Points For Points Against Win Percentage Postseason
2 4 88 134 33,33%

SUPERCUP (9 seasons)
Wins Losses Points For Points Against Win Percentage
110 25 7335 6818 1182 81,48%

Wins Postseason Losses Postseason Points For Points Against Win Percentage Postseason
0 0 0 0 0,00%

No participation in CoC

Won NC Conference Championships in league 2.2 in Season 1
Won Division Title NC East in league 2.2 in season 1
Won Division Title NC West in league 1.1 in Season 2, 3, 4 and 5

Went to the post season in season 1 in league 2.2 (conference championship)
Went to the post season in season 2 in league 1.1 (divisional playoff exit)
Went to the post season in season 3 in league 1.1 (divisional playoff exit)
Went to the post season in season 4 in league 1.1 (divisional playoff exit)
Went to the post season in season 5 in league 1.1 (divisional playoff exit)

The Rivne Monarchs came into the league on the second gameday in season 1.
They won their division and the NC conference in 2.2 that year and went into the 1.1 the next season.
They were able to win their division in the 1.1 4 times in a row and had then some problems with training and this resulted in quite some money problems.
In season 8 this became such an big issue that they basically had to tier down their team and the manager lost his motivation during the offseason.
The team went officially BOT before the 5th gameday of the regular season in season 9.

Why in the HOF?
Also an early team, which dominated the NC West for some time.
They made it into the playoffs 5 straight years, 4 in the 1.1

Why not in the HOF?
As an early team, they had all the benefits of being ahead of all later incoming teams.
Once their 1 skill training went out of hands the team went down.

Zingers
hansend
In with season 3
reached 1.1 in season 5
out with Season 9 (only 4 seasons in the 1.1)

Record

LEAGUE lower 1.1 (1 Season)
Wins Losses Points For Points Against Win Percentage
39 9 1986 463 81,25%

Wins Postseason Losses Postseason Points For Points Against Win Percentage Postseason
1 2 57 26 33,33%

LEAGUE 1.1 or higher (4 seasons)
Wins Losses Points For Points Against Win Percentage
12 52 803 3099 18,75%

Wins Postseason Losses Postseason Points For Points Against Win Percentage Postseason
0 0 0 0 0,00%

SUPERCUP (7 seasons)
Wins Losses Points For Points Against Win Percentage
72 33 4809 1822 68,57%

Wins Postseason Losses Postseason Points For Points Against Win Percentage Postseason
0 1 7 28 0,00%

No participation in CoC

Won Division Title AC East in league 2.1 in season 4
Won Division Title NC North in league 2.2 in Season 7

Went to the post season in season 4 in league 2.1 (conference championship exit)
Went to the post season in season 7 in league 2.2 (divisional playoffs exit)

Went to supercup playoffs in season 8 (1. round exit)

Zinger was one of those early teams struggling with the at that time already quite high rated teams in the 1.1
Those teams came into the 1.1 and got basically hammered and had to go down again after one or two seasons, only to come back to get hammered again.
Zinger came into the league 2.1 late in season 3 and went not with a BOT flush (or was not selected, also possible) and had to play another season in the 2.1.
They won their division with a perfect record and went all the way to the conference championship, where they lost.
They won their relegation game against a BOT team from 1.1 and had little success in the 1.1 the next 2 seasons.
Zingers had to relegate without a deciding game and won their division in the 2.2 again with a perfect record, only to lose in the divisional playoffs.
They came back into the 1.1 with a BOT flush and played again an unsuccessfully season (season 8) and went BOT early in season 9 (gameday 4).

Why in the HOF?
They were member of the Monarchs region for 7 season and did not give up, when they went down from 1.1

Why not in the HOF?
They had basically no real idea what the game was about and had even after 6 season not a really mid strength team.

I love this idea.
A regional H of Fame is a great idea,
but I can't vote for any of these teams.

Why not?
For me the idea is to honor managers playing the game, not their record breaking performances.
It helps of cause to stay ahead of the game, but there are several managers/teams on the list which were always fun to play and chat with and who were at that time a team to beat to win it all.
Granted, not all of the teams should make it into the HOF, but 3 out of 8 does look good for me.

Regardless, here is my vote:

Jena Yellow Aces - 20
Dutch Tigers - 18
Casate New Canaries - 16
Rivne Monarchs - 14
AFC Luku Tábor - 12
trestleberg - 10
Zingers - 8
Mayhem - 6

my vote

Dutch Tigers - 20
Casate New Canaries - 18
Jena Yellow Aces - 16
Rivne Monarchs - 14
AFC Luku Tábor - 12
trestleberg - 10
Mayhem - 8
Zingers - 6

Friendly reminder to vote here

Don't forget to vote here.
Everybody can do this.

Dutch Tigers - 20
Rivne Monarchs - 18
Jena Yellow Aces - 16
AFC Luku Tábor - 14
Casate New Canaries - 12
trestleberg - 10
Zingers - 8
Mayhem - 6