no content
AdBlocker active?
It seems you are using software to block advertisements. You could help us if you could switch it off when visiting redzoneaction.org.
The reason is very simple: Advertisements help us running the site, to offer you the game in a good quality for free. So if you like the game, please support us by purchasing a Supporter Account or disabling the AdBlocker on this site.
Thank you very much!
| Main / Suggestions / Only show Trophies/Achievements for Current Owner Search Forum | |||||||||
| Navigation: |< 2 3 4 > >| | |||||||||
| Rating: | |||||||||
Poll: Should trophies stay at the team when going bot?,
Poll closed,
votes: 189
|
|||||||||
| Poster | Message | ||||||||
|
sh8888
|
posted: 2012-04-26 10:21:30 (ID: 37403) Report Abuse | ||||||||
|
I noticed a team that had won a trophy (probably Conference Championship) in Season 1, the trophy was listed in the "trophy room" on the Front Office Overview .... but the team had been through many changes of ownership since this season 1 trophy, seems a bit bizarre to me as the trophy wasn't won by the current owner.
Therefore my suggestion is .....only show a Trophy in the Trophy Room if it has been won by the current owner ....when a new manager inherits a team it should show empty in the Trophy Room until a trophy has been won during their current period of ownership. |
|||||||||
| Quote Reply Edit | |||||||||
| posted: 2012-04-26 10:56:09 (ID: 37404) Report Abuse | |||||||||
|
I am halfway undecided here.
When the NFL Team XY won the Bowl in 1956, and got new owners meanwhile, the trophies still belong to that team, everyone will say XY, SB Winner '56 |
|||||||||
| Quote Reply Edit | |||||||||
|
Buffalo
|
posted: 2012-04-26 10:59:19 (ID: 37407) Report Abuse | ||||||||
|
pete wrote:
I am halfway undecided here. When the NFL Team XY won the Bowl in 1956, and got new owners meanwhile, the trophies still belong to that team, everyone will say XY, SB Winner '56 Good argument. May be you can put the manager, who won the trophy, in bracletts behind the trophy name. |
|||||||||
| Quote Reply Edit | |||||||||
|
preachie
|
posted: 2012-04-26 11:00:57 (ID: 37409) Report Abuse | ||||||||
|
pete wrote:
I am halfway undecided here. When the NFL Team XY won the Bowl in 1956, and got new owners meanwhile, the trophies still belong to that team, everyone will say XY, SB Winner '56 Good point, on the other hand when a new manager takes over a team here in RZA world, it's a very new team. The team name is different (I guess in most cases the new owner will rename it), the stadium is reset to default and even the team squad is different, so I wouldn't see it as the 'same' team. However, it's possible to argue for both directions and both parties would be "right". It's term of definition  |
|||||||||
| Quote Reply Edit | |||||||||
|
Tarjan
|
posted: 2012-04-26 11:07:39 (ID: 37410) Report Abuse | ||||||||
|
preachie wrote:
The team name is different (I guess in most cases the new owner will rename it), the stadium is reset to default and even the team squad is different, so I wouldn't see it as the 'same' team. It somehow feels like a new Franchise. Something to think about: If the old browns had won anything in the past which Team today (ravens/ New Browns) will call those achievements their own??? Last edited on 2012-04-26 11:07:59 by Tarjan |
|||||||||
| Quote Reply Edit | |||||||||
|
sh8888
|
posted: 2012-04-26 11:16:04 (ID: 37413) Report Abuse | ||||||||
|
preachie wrote:
pete wrote:
I am halfway undecided here. When the NFL Team XY won the Bowl in 1956, and got new owners meanwhile, the trophies still belong to that team, everyone will say XY, SB Winner '56 Good point, on the other hand when a new manager takes over a team here in RZA world, it's a very new team. The team name is different (I guess in most cases the new owner will rename it), the stadium is reset to default and even the team squad is different, so I wouldn't see it as the 'same' team. However, it's possible to argue for both directions and both parties would be "right". It's term of definition I see both points of view, however I'll give you an RZA example to try and illustrate my point ....... Take Notsch's team as the example .... he won many things last season. but ... imagine if his team had gone Bot just before season rollover and therefore been relegated to 2.1/2.2 in the bot flush. A new manager picks up the team , he's got a full trophy cabinet ... but (in my opinion only) this is nuts ! because he's achieved nothing , won nothing and in reality his team is really Team 2.1.25 (or whatever) and not Notsch's old winning franchise. I do see the real life world i.e. San Francisco five times superbowl champions etc etc ... but that is a franchise with continuity ... there is absolutely ZERO continuity in the "franchise" here because it's not a 'franchise', it's more like a 'placeholder'. However, keep the debate going ...I'm always happy to hear the opposing views  |
|||||||||
| Quote Reply Edit | |||||||||
|
JonnyP
|
posted: 2012-04-26 11:17:21 (ID: 37414) Report Abuse | ||||||||
|
No lets not...
All opposing views are stupid. Change it  |
|||||||||
| Quote Reply Edit | |||||||||
| posted: 2012-04-26 12:33:09 (ID: 37423) Report Abuse | |||||||||
|
JonnyP wrote:
No lets not... All opposing views are stupid. Change it 
Poll added! |
|||||||||
| Quote Reply Edit | |||||||||
|
Quimriera
|
posted: 2012-04-26 13:51:39 (ID: 37431) Report Abuse | ||||||||
|
My argument:
The cups are not given to the team, are given to the manager. When the manager is gone, the cups disappear. Simple. 
|
|||||||||
| Quote Reply Edit | |||||||||
|
barbados1
|
posted: 2012-04-26 14:15:32 (ID: 37434) Report Abuse | ||||||||
|
pete wrote:
When the NFL Team XY won the Bowl in 1956, and got new owners meanwhile, the trophies still belong to that team, everyone will say XY, SB Winner '56 Sorry, but the Superbowl didn't start until 1967.  |
|||||||||
| Quote Reply Edit | |||||||||
| reply Mark this thread unread | |||||||||
| Navigation: |< 2 3 4 > >| | |||||||||
| Main / Suggestions / Only show Trophies/Achievements for Current Owner | |||||||||
